Yep. That's fairly apparent with a quick look at them- and it's kind of nice to see how poor the finish is. Makes me think maybe I'm not as bad at spinning as I had thought. I'll probably make a couple if I run across any thin sheet bronze for the right price, but I have a lot of other more important priorities.
That may be true, but it really isn't any of my concern. My job in this is to trim them down to a smaller size so they *look* new. He's been happy with the two I've finished so far, and I figure he's the guy whose opinion counts in the matter- not mine or yours! Could be he's just using the refurbished ones for screwing around out in the garage, and saving the good ones for when he plays in public.