I use double sided tape, most specifically the creative memories. In the long run it really is way, way cheaper than buying glue sticks as you only need to roll it onto the corners when doing photos or papers, and there is 34 feet of tape. I scrap all the time, for hours at a time... meaning I am extremely productive and It takes me about 4 or 5 months, sometimes more before I run out of tape. Yes, there is the initial cost of buying the dispenser (which is filled) at about $7. As a dilligent worker I use two rolls of tape a year, at most. HOWEVER, THEY CAN BE FOUND ON EBAY FOR MUCH LESS.
I've never had the tape fail. It is permenant although youdo have a little bit of time beore it really sets so if you need to make an adjustment it is not a problem at all.
Further, I have been scrapbooking for 26 years and have used all types of glues. They really tend to deteriorate over time. Scrapbooks that I made 15 years ago with double sided adhesive are still in tact. The ones I glued, are not. So, I'm a firm believer in the tape.
Good luck in your search for what is right for you!
Melissa in Seattle