massively OT: depressing/frustrating Katrina relief news

Looks like, in our area at least, the right hand doesn't know what the left hand is doing, and some of the hands aren't honest.

Many, many Walmart gift cards were bought in the days after the storm, and people who bought them gave them to various organizations (Red Cross, Salvation Army, United Way, etc.) for distribution. Now it turns out that a lot of the cards are missing in action--no one knows how many there were total, where they went, who has them, how many were given out, etc. Apparently even the folks handing them out weren't keeping any sort of list, because there are known cases of families sending in multiple members to pick them up, or else going in day after day. It has come to the point that some families have received none and others have gotten several each day, while one evacuee famliy was seen at Walmart with big stacks of the cards, buying two televisions. The United Way had cards, but couldn't distribute them because they "didn't have the proper forms." The people in the shelters are finding out much more information about assistance and receiving much more help than those who have been able to stay with friends or find temporary housing. Cards and other assistance comes to the shelters, where it is snapped up, leaving nothing for other evacuees.

It also turns out that, here at least, agencies are helping those who were homeless in N.O. before they are helping people who had some sort of shelter there. Are they not equally homeless now? There are plenty of people who had a roof in N.O. but who have no insurance and were barely making it month to month. My friend's Mom was told by FEMA and the local agency info clearinghouse to "call her insurance agent" and that people on public assistance in N.O. had priority. That doesn't help her find an apartment or a job here in another state, now, does it? This woman and her daughter have had to get the local paper involved to try to expose and sort out what is going on.

I'm not trying to start a flame war about which charities or agencies are or are not doing a good job. I'm sure much of what is going on here is disorganization and a few greedy people, rather than any sort of plot. But you may well want to think about where you give time and money, and try to make sure it is actually going to people who need it, to be given to those people by folks who have their ducks in a row.

Monique in TX

Reply to
monique
Loading thread data ...

I think these kinds of things happen in any disaster and in every day life. It's a situation of donor be aware.

Reply to
maryd

I wondered how relief was going to come to people who evacuated and now find themselves homeless. What? How are they going to help those people if they don't get back to New Orleans?

Cindy

Reply to
teleflora

It's probably a combination of lots of things. Unfortunately, this is the way it goes for awhile during a disaster like this. I don't think you are flaming any organization. I think all of us need to remember that this is the worst disaster of this type in this country. I know it must be difficult to comprehend what the evacuees and the people with the different organizations are dealing with. The charities in Dallas will allow you to sort clothes, but you can't go to any of the shelters without "training." The Salvation Army here has asked that no more clothes be given because they have enough clothes for about 4 warehouses. Reunion Arena here will probably be empty by the end of the week. Houston is making way with getting their evacuees settled elsewhere. A lot of states of joining in not only for New Orleans, which has received the most publicity, but also for Mississippi where entire towns are now gone.

Sherry Starr

Reply to
Sherry Starr

It seems to me that this is America experiencing something like what Europe had with Bosnia. Relief efforts there were not too bad, but a lot of it was organized in a very small-scale way - groups of people or tiny ad hoc charities getting together to drive a vanload of stuff all the way themselves.

This had another effect beside being more reliable - it meant that the donors and people around them built up personal links with the place their stuff was going to. So they learnt a lot about places they'd never even heard of before the relief effort started. It was probably the first war situation where that happened.

I see that American church groups are doing this kind of thing already, and I see it as a welcome development. The more direct links get set up, the better-informed people will be.

We did something like that, taking a consignment of nutritional supplements for Muslim refugees in Croatia. We left the choice of which charity would get them to a Croatian local (she picked the Merhamet, which is like a Muslim version of Christian Aid, i.e. religiously motivated but non-sectarian in who they helped).

============== j-c ====== @ ====== purr . demon . co . uk ============== Jack Campin: 11 Third St, Newtongrange EH22 4PU, Scotland | tel 0131 660 4760 for CD-ROMs and free | fax 0870 0554 975 stuff: Scottish music, food intolerance, & Mac logic fonts | mob 07800 739 557

Reply to
Jack Campin - bogus address

InspirePoint website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.