A long tedious musing with a wobbly tip for turners

This morning I screwed a 11" vase held on a faceplate back on my lathe to re-turn the neck and make it a little less tacky. The unsupported neck end wobbled quite a bit and I assumed the old axiom or urban myth, "replaced work is never centered" had got me. This is about _replaced_ work and I understand that blanks originally misaligned on a faceplate can be turned to round. Like woodturners, faceplates need not be perfect to be useful.

The spindle and faceplate threads had looked ok so I hadn't cleaned them. I took a closer look and there it was, a smashed miniscule chip. I mean just a meer wisp. This time I cleaned the threads and now there was almost no wobble.

I decided to clock by eyeball the runout along a 2 X 10 maple cylinder made as smooth and accurate as I could turn it. It was held on a clean good quality face plate without tail support. Not the accurate precisely controlled (except for oversight) govt. grant experiment with stipend, travel and meal allowances, but good enough for a NASA subcontractor or this 'shadetree scientist'. Certainly not the contribution to mankind like the study that proved overeating makes you fat.

I digress, but anyway the blank ran quite concentrically at the spindle and with no significant runout as I looked along the shaft. Then I interposed various bits of debris, shavings, pieces of thread, washers that weren't machined spacers, even a bit of dried varnish. Turns out I didn't need to be funded by a govt. grant for a dial indicator electron microscope to see the runout as I neared the blank's end. It was clearly visible and significant. (however I could have used the prestige, stipend and the meal & travel allowances)

What I'm trying to say in as many words as possible is, "Don't assume that your lathe's spindle and fixings threads are clean". Wipe them each time. An unseen wisp of debris makes a wobble that will increase as the blank is longer. It's worse than some of you may think.

Turn to Safety, Arch Fortiter

formatting link

Reply to
Arch
Loading thread data ...

"Arch" wrote: (clip) An unseen wisp of debris makes a wobble that will increase as the blank is longer. It's worse than some of you may think. ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ This is one of those obvious-after-it's-pointed-out facts. Thanks for pointing it out.

Reply to
Leo Lichtman

So a bit of flakiness results in being off-center? I have been accused of that all my life. It's nice to know it can be more universally applied to woodturning, as well. -mike

Reply to
Mike Paulson

Hi Arch

Yes Arch and this also applies to other things, for instance, drilling a to be accurate deeper hole with your drill press, and it seems to have gone off kilter, first thing people blame is the drill bit (people assume the table is at 90 degrees) you'd be surprised how far a bit goes off with the table just a tad out of 90 degrees or the table not clamped tight, check it out you'll be surprised.

Seems like every time I got into trouble was the time I assumed something or other.

Have fun and take care Leo Van Der Loo

Arch wrote:

Reply to
l.vanderloo

wrote: (clip) Seems like every time I got into trouble was the time I assumed something or other. ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ The countless assumptions you make every day that don't get you into trouble go unnoticed. :-)

Reply to
Leo Lichtman

Tedious, indeed.

Must you?

J.

Reply to
John

Hi J. Probably not. :)

Turn to Safety, Arch Fortiter

formatting link

Reply to
Arch

InspirePoint website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.