Hollowing Tools

I had just about convinced myself to bite the bullet and buy the Kelton small hollowing tool set for about $125. I just happened to be flipping through some old magfaziine articles last night, and came acorss one where the guy claims that he had a "death grip" on the tool, and it still wanted to grab using either of the two hooked tools.

In the States, I think my only other real choice is the Sorby RS200KT for about $72. I like the fact that it has replacable tips where the Kelton does not.

Can anyone offer any insights as to why I should buy one over the other? I'm not looking at going really deep, at least not to start with, but even so, I think the mini turning set by Sorby is too small.

Thanks, tms

Reply to
Tim Schubach
Loading thread data ...

Funny, but I recently read a positive review by Ellsworth of some proprietary hollowing system in a catalog. Maybe he does use other things.

Derek

Reply to
Derek Hartzell

Why not just make a set of hollowing tools? It is not hard and they work find. It is all David Ellsworth uses.

Reply to
Darrell Feltmate

Hi Tim, I have the Kelton large set and they work quite good. Yes they can be grabby but if you rotate the tool slightly counterclockwise they will perform fine. I believe there is instructions on the Kelton site for proper use. I think you will find most all hollowing tools will be grabby if thier not presented in the right orientation. I also have the stewart hooker and it acts similar to the Keltons. End grain hollowing isn't quite as smooth as cutting facegrain with a bowl gouge so you have to expect your tools to act a bit differently. The Keltons sharpen quite easily with a diamond file. The amount of metal lost to sharpen is nill.

Bob, Naugatuck Ct.

formatting link

Reply to
Bob Pritchard

Although this article is a bit out of date, it covers a wide range of hollowing tools available for all sizes of hollow forms. If you do a Google on "Mangiameli" and this group, you will find more up-to-date information.

Joe Fleming - San Diego

Reply to
Joe Fleming

Derek I am willing to stand corrected. On his tape about hollow turning, he was using only his own home made tools although he does sell them. Was he advocating his own or someone else's?

Reply to
Darrell Feltmate

Reply to
Graeme Campbell

Try John Jordan's new turning tools, he has a large set and a small set with removeable tips. Got mine about a month ago and works like a charm. He sells them with or with out a handle. The arm brace type fits them (the large set) well if you already have one. Have no affiliation at all but they work great for me.

Reply to
Buddy Riley

InspirePoint website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.