OT: Harry Potter #6

Received the book in the mail today, and read it in one sitting, took about 6 hours. Well crafted, a couple of slow spots and very much darker than the first book. A lot of loose ends are tied up and there is a twist at the end.

Harry is definately finding out that adults are falible, too, and that he's going have to stand on his own two feet in this world. I won't tell the plot, as I'm sure many are still reading, but I must admit - I prefer the earlier books - they are more light-hearted, which is my preference. Given the way the series is going, I'm wondering just how dark the 7th book is going to be!

I would not recommend it for children under 10 unless they are mature for thier age. It is, IMHO, *Not* a child's series at all any more, and should not be sold as such. Much like Tolkien's books, the first were for children, the rest were not.

Reply to
fran
Loading thread data ...

I picked it up last night and just started it. (I'm waiting for my next cup of tea to be ready!) We've decided that we won't be reading anymore of them to DD (age 6+), she got scared in #3 and we stopped. But in another year or two, I suspect she'll start the series herself.

I'll add my two cents > Received the book in the mail today, and read it in one sitting, took

Reply to
Cheryl Isaak

I noticed that the last film we`ve had was a lot darker than the first two. So I wonder just what the next three films will be like! And since we adults seem to enjoy them so much, should they REALLY be classed as kids` books? And is J.K. Rowling not quite what she seems?

Pat P

Reply to
EAXStitch

What does she seem to you to be that she's not quite like? (Please don't even try to correct the English in that sentence; it just isn't worth the time or the effort)

Lucille

Reply to
Lucille

If anyone is planning to give any details at all about the book, please put the word "spoiler" in the subject line. Our financial future is currently on thin ice and the waiting list at the library is huge so some of us won't be able to read it for a looooooooooong time.

Reply to
Brenda Lewis

LOL! I know what you mean, Lucille, and it`s too hot anyway! She always seems so nice, but does she dabble in the Black Arts, I wonder?

Pat P

Reply to
EAXStitch

Well *I* can`t - I haven`t read it! I always wait for theDVDs to come out!!! Can`t be bothered to go to the cinema with all the hassle of parking, paying, sitting with crowds of people when I can wait and see it in the comfort of my own home - pause it to go to the loo, get something to eat, or just take a break from it! At least I can still stitch ewhile I`m watching a film - I can`t stitch and read!

Pat P

Reply to
EAXStitch

Or maybe she's talented the way the Grimm Brothers were. The fairy tales in their original state were very dark and very scary. When I was a kid I thought they were great reading and although they frightened me, I liked them a lot. As a matter of fact I still have my original copies of the Red, Blue and Yellow fairy books.

Before anyone remarks, they aren't first editions. I'm old but not that old !!!

Lucille

Reply to
Lucille

Aren't there only three DVD's/movies of the series out? I wonder when the next ones will be available. Anyone know?

-- Carey

Reply to
Carey N.

One usually seems to come out not long after a book comes out - usually around August, I think. Haven`t heard anything yet, though - and there`s normally a poster in W.H.Smith`s asking people to pre-order. On Amazon, too.

Pat P

Reply to
EAXStitch

The DVDs are not the same as the books. I think of the movies as related products, enjoyable for what they are, but not substitutes for the books (there's so much that's left out!) I like to listen to the audio books while stitching (because you're right, you can't read and stitch, and the books are HUGE!)

Alison

Reply to
Alison

The interesting thing about the series is that there are lots of people who are annoyed at Harry's growing up and the books getting darker, etc. Why couldn't it just stay cozy and friendly? Well, I think the books are linked to Harry's growing up - they are becoming darker and more mature (this has been going on probably since book 4 or so.) And after all, how cheery can a book about the struggle between good and evil be? There are times that I wonder if we should even put the books in the juvenile section of the library any more (we have them in both juvenile and young adult.)

Alison

Reply to
Alison

But it's not the movie associated with the book that just came out. The movies lag the books by several volumes.

Best wishes, Ericka

Reply to
Ericka Kammerer

Firstly, the books cannot be substituted by the movies. Too much information and richness is lost due to editing for suitable time requirements. If you cannot take the time to read the books themselves, I have heard of many gaining the richness of the experience through the audio versions. Nice background atmosphere whilst stitching. Next, the next theatrical release is planned for Nov (covering Goblet of Fire/ Book 4). Another caveat, a lot of plotline and story was sacrificed in this movie (or so I've heard). Lastly, I have finished and love Book 6. True, the format is changing. That is causing some discomfort among some readers. These characters are growing up, becoming adults and individuals. The "tried and true" tack for the pacing of a typical school year could not last. Different strengths are becoming evident in the series and all the better for it. The fate of good and evil and all magic-kind cannot be encompassed within the structure of a school year. Now to shed the last of my tears from the end of this book (and I did really cry while reading this one) and cheer Harry on...

~Connie~

Reply to
FeySidhe

Right. We're currently awaiting the theatrical release of Goblet of Fire (Book Four). It will be a good many months, closer to a year, before that hits DVD. And Half-Blood Prince is Book Six.

Plus, the movies simply cannot replicate the books. The films are good, but the books are so much better. And...hmm, how to explain this?...For us, at least, the movies don't scale out the same as the books. For DH and me, Prizoner of Azkaban is far and away the best book, but the weakest of the movies.

But to each his or her own, of course.

Karen E., whose copy of Half-Blood Prince has three bookmarks in it in different places: one for her, one for DH and one for read-aloud with the kids.

Reply to
Karen E

No, of course not - they`re about three books behind. Looks like I should have made that clearer but thought everyone would realise that! ;-))

Pat P

Reply to
EAXStitch

That`s another reason not to read them for me - can`t be doing with huge books - my one working hand goes numb if I hold things too long, then it hurts like hell when the feeling comes back - and if I read I like to lie back and enjoy it!

When I was getting over my stroke, my DH read The Lord of the Rings to me out loud, from cover to cover. Maybe I can get him to read the Harry Potter books to me.

Who does the reading in the audio books? That might be an idea, as long as it was the right voice.

Pat P

Reply to
EAXStitch

If I remember names correctly, Jim Dale does the American editions (whom I've heard reading segments on NBC morning's Today). He does an excellent rendition. He actually performs and keeps track of different voices for "all" characters, not a small feat by any means. Whereas for the "homegrown" British side of the pond, I think a gentleman by the name of Stephen Frye (?) does it. I am not 100% on this fact, so please do not hold me to it.

~Connie~

Reply to
FeySidhe

Stephen Frye does the UK version of the audio?!? Awesome! You lucky ducks!

Karen E., with just the first book on CD, US version.

Reply to
Karen E

In that case I`ll definitely get them. Did anyone see him in Tom Brown`s Schooldays?" Wonderful performance. WHAT a voice.

Pat P

Reply to
EAXStitch

InspirePoint website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.