Teaching Quilting

This is kind of a test message, as I am setting up thunderbird for reading news groups, and seeing if it is "better" than XPN newsreader.

Well, anyway, this video, from man sewing, one of my favorite you tube channels (perhaps I will do a future post about it):

formatting link
and in it Rob Appell, the host of the show, helps his daughter with making a doll quilt. I personally think he did a little too much, though.

There is also this video about how the Janome 2212 is the best machine for beginners:

formatting link
There are also lots of others that talk about the best machine for beginners as well.

This got me to wondering something that is sort of a hypothetical question for me, but might be more something that one of you has actual experience with.

Suppose you are teaching a teenager how to sew or quilt, and one day his parents come to you and say that they want to get him a sewing machine for his birthday, with you being the technical person, and them supplying the money, with a budget of up to $200.

Would you recommend an older machine such as a singer featherweight or

301, or a newer "beginner" machine like the Janome 2212 (the 2212 is not a "toy" machine, as I would never even consider a "toy" machine in this situation).

I have a singer featherweight, which is kinda my "inheritance" from my late mother. I love it, and I have a buttonhole attachement for it which makes really nice buttonholes, and a bunch of presser feet for various things, of which I have only used the "regular" one and the 1/4" foot, but otherwise it is limited to straight stitching.

I also have a new home from the early 60's (I think), that is a really nice machine that is a zig-zag machine.

I would also like a singer 301, though I really don't know what I would do with a 3rd machine.

So if I were buying the machine for myself, I would choose an older machine, specifically a Singer 301. For the teenager, however I might not.

The 301 (or a featherweight) is probably the better built machine, as there is a reason they have been around since the 50's (I think), or, in the case of the featherweight, the 40's or earlier.

However, the newer machine, the 2212, has several advantages as well:

I have heard that threading the machine is a bit easier and more "foolproof" on newer machines, and I don't mean just threading the needle, though some newer machines have an attachment for automatically doing that as well. I mean getting the thread through the tension disks and the tension lever is easier.

Most general purpose machines today (and the 2212 in particular) have a freearm. I have never used a freearm, but I think they would come in quite handy if the machine was used primarily for garment construction. I don't think they would be very useful for quilting.

There is nothing new about freearms as there is a model of the Singer Featherweight (222) that has one, but I think the newer the machine, the more likely it is to have one, and a 301 definitely does not, I don't think. Heck, there might even be model of treadle made with a freearm.

The buttonhole attachement is probably easier to use than the one for the featherweight. The featherweight attachment makes really nice buttonholes, but I had a heck of a time getting it set up properly the first time I used it. The attachement for the 301 looks like it is similar.

The stich selection seems to be simpler on the 2212, and it contains several decorative stiches as well.

Obviously, a featherweight, since it is limited to straight stiching, has no decorative stiches. My New Home has decorative stitches, but you have to mess around with cams for that, and I have never used them except messing around with them to see what they look like, and the only one I might use is the one for blind-stitch hemming. If they were easier to use, though, I might. I don't know about the 301 and decorative stitches.

Many newer machines, though not the 2212, have a drop in bobbin, which I am told is easier to use than a front-loading bobbin. Winding a bobbin is still a pain in the royal butt (M*A*S*H fans might get that reference), so the availability of prewound bobbins for the machine you are considering might also be a factor.

There are probably other differences to consider as well, but those seem to be most of the advantages of a newer machine over an older one.

There are other, even simpler machines out there, but some appear to be too simple to go much past beginner level sewing. The 2212 looks like it could go well past beginner level sewing.

Brian Christiansen (I hope my name does not appear twice, as thunderbird is supposed to automatically attach it, but I am not sure if I have it set up correctly as it does not appear in the message I am typing.)

Reply to
Brian Christiansen
Loading thread data ...

What kind of sewing is the machine going to be used for? If only quilting, then zigzag and free arm probably aren't necessary. If it will be used for garment sewing, then zigzag and free arm are very desirable.

One advantage of newer machines is the ability to limit the speed. My Elna has a slider-type control that I can set anywhere between "turtle" and "rabbit". It can force beginners (or anyone) to slow down.

Julia > This is kind of a test message, as I am setting up thunderbird for

Reply to
Julia in MN

I guess that is part of the problem, as the person you are teaching does not yet know where his or her interest will take them, to primarily quilting, primarily garment making, or "half and half" of each

As for the speed control, does this come on "beginner" machines, or do you have to have an expensive high-end machine for this feature. I know it exists, I am just not sure what machines it exists on. Since it is not known if a beginning sewist will maintain an interest, I, at least would recommend against an expensive high-end machine.

--
Brian Christiansen
Reply to
Brian Christiansen

I agree about not recommending an expensive high-end machine, but at the other extreme, I wouldn't recommend a cheap machine from a big box store. You don't want someone turned off to sewing because of a machine that doesn't work properly. I would definitely recommend buying from a reliable local dealer that will service the machine and answer questions, including lessons on using the machine.

I don't know whether the speed control comes on beginner machines. I do know that both my Elna Quilter's Dream and the older, smaller Elna Stella have that feature. The Quilter's Dream is definitely not a low-end machine, but not as expensive as some other machines.

I prefer a drop-in bobbin, but that may be because that's what I have always had. I've used other machines, but found it more difficult to get the bobbin in place properly.

Janome has a good reputation around here. I wouldn't hesitate to buy Janome.

Julia > >> What kind of sewing is the machine going to be used for?

Reply to
Julia in MN

I don't even recall mentioning considering a cheap machine from Wal-Mart or a place like that in the first place. If Kenmore (Sears) still sold machines, I would recommend those, but apparently they don't, and Kenmores are really Janomes anyway.

Well, if that, and if Sears were what it used to be, with a service dept. and all that. With its demise over the last 20 years, and its merger with K-Mart (I think, and if that is correct, that move dropped the company's value considerably in my eyes), I am not so sure about even that.

In fact, if I were playing the role of "technical advisor" in the situation I described, the very first thing I would recommend is not buying the machine online or from a place like Wal-Mart.

The 2212 is certainly not the most expensive machine, but it is not a cheap machine from a big box store either. You could of course buy one onine, but there is also an authorized Janome dealer here in Tucson.

Getting it online is Probably a bit cheaper than getting it at or through (it may not be one of their regular products) the dealer, but as you say servicing and lessons might also be included. I don't even know if that machine is even available at Wal-Mart or a place like it.

The Janome dealer in Tucson is also a "quilt shop," and does offer classes, though I do not know if they offer classes for any specific machine.

I think that New Home is really Janome, so I guess my New Home machine that I mentioned is a Janome.

--
Brian Christiansen
Reply to
Brian Christiansen

I think where you live might well have as much to do with what you get as w hat you need.

Where I am we are down to one repair shop that is also an authorized Bernin a dealer. There just is no place you can buy a new machine except for a be rnina anywhere near here.

So when I am asked about starter machines I recommend either getting a seco nd hand old fashioned purely mechanical machine and a book about how to mai ntain and repair them, or get a cheap junk machine from one of the big box stores with the plan to replace it fairly often. I do point out the Bernin a place and the fact that I am unfamiliar with Berninas. Unless the person is willing to drive over the hill and far away, these are the options. I have ended up teaching french seams to some new sewing people who got old s traight stitch machines as a result of this advice, but french seams are ve ry easy and take about 10 minutes to teach. The people who buy a big box m achine usually end up either getting a bernina very soon, or driving the di stance to shop someplace with more selection. I do point out that if you are spending more than a little (used machines o ften cost very little) you really want to test drive a machine to see if yo u are comfortable with it. I generally discourage starting out on a machin e with too much fancy boo. There is really nothing much a solid zig zag ma chine cannot do that many of the fancy dancy ones can, it just might take a little longer and a bit of fussing. Neither does a newbie need the distra ction, frustration, and temptation, of whiz bangs and weirdities.

NightMist

l.

t.

ar.

Reply to
Night Mist

I agree with what Nightmist said. If a new sewer does not know if their interest will remain, just like in an y new endeavor, you do not want to get top-of-the-line in anything. Heck, e ven a used machine off craigslist, an estate sale, or a traded-in machine a t the local shop can be used to launch the interest. Learning how to care f or the machine is a necessity. Simple features, so the learning curve is si mple. nothing more of a turn-off than to have an overwhelming amount of opt ions presented. Small steps are always best.

G> This is kind of a test message, as I am setting up thunderbird for

l.

t.

ar.

Reply to
gingerwcgc

Hello Brian, There are lots of quilt sewing on Missouri Star Quilting Co. and Rob Appell works for them. We get the mans take on quilting. I have always had Brother sewing machines and would recommend these to anyone. Amazon.com have several at under $200. Have 2 of these machines both electronic. Sandy$

Reply to
morningdove2011

InspirePoint website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.