Ashley Isles Gouges...

Was looking over the Isles selection of gouges - sorta curious about the brand as I've heard good comments but haven't looked into them before. In the process I came across a term that leaves me a little perplexed:

Mario Rodriguez's 1.25" shallow spindle gouge in HSS ($116): "The sheer size and weight of the tool makes it a bit expensive, but the heft makes it easy to control. It's a production tool for the occasional turner. 1-1/4" (37 mm) wide."

They've used the same "for the occasional turner" comment for at least one other Isles tool - what do you think this means? How can you have a "production tool" but for "occasional turning"?

Reply to
Owen Lowe
Loading thread data ...

I think they realize that hobby turners outnumber professionals.

Sort of like the "extras" involved in packing up a bunch of chunks of steel into a box, it's euphony, pleasant sounds designed to cover the lack of significance.

Reply to
George

Hello Owen,

I believe that "for the occasional turner" is ment to imply that it is a very good production tool, even if you are only a hobby turner. I agree with them that it is an excellent spindle tool. Not a bowl gouge mind you, but a spindle gouge. I have one that my wife quickly acquired for her tool kit. She allows me to borrow it occasionally, guess that makes me an occasional turner. If you are turning lots of spindles this is an excellent tool that will do the work of most spindle tools. It is too big to turn small coves however.

Fred Holder

Reply to
Fred Holder

My take on it is that they mean this as a tool for someone who turns occasionally in a production environment, i.e. a production woodworker who occasionally needs to turn items, but doesn't want or need to amass the bewildering array of tools we woodturners do, but would rather have just one or two that will cover most of his needs. TBH it looks a bit like the kind of gouge whatsisname on the New Yankee Workshop uses for absolutely *everything* he turns.

Reply to
Alun

Have you noticed that advertising hype is sometimes murky and meaningless if you really pay attention to what is said? I think that may be the case here.

Reply to
Barry N. Turner

InspirePoint website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.