Musing about turning proverbs. Facts or opinions? What's your take?

Pulling cuts remove wood faster, but tear the blank more than push cuts which are slower, but finish better. Always?

"Scraping is a pulling cut with the wood doing the pulling". This proverb probably pulls my leg more than the wood.

"Impeccable poor taste can be the perfection of imperfection". Depends on the judge & jury.

"If you don't like a turning, look closer". Of course, you may like it even less.

"It looks wrong and it feels wrong, but it can be right". Delusions of adequacy?

"What is left off is as important as what is left on or put on". My shavings and chips don't seem all that important or my lacquer quite that unimportant.

"Tool marks indicate poor craftsmanship". Deliberate tool marks need not, but they could be markers that suggest it.

"You have to spoil a good turning a little bit in order to get it right". How spoiled?

"Good turners learn the rules, good artists forget them". There may not be any rules. "The more perfect the technique, the less it is noticed". Maybe true for laymen, but not for turners.

"When grinding gouges swing the wings, twist the flute". Makes sense to me. So does lag the scraper, lead the flute.

"A secondary bevel is not a bevel, it's a relief angle". I agree. No matter how short, the angle leading to the edge is the bevel.

Turn to Safety, Arch Fortiter

formatting link

Reply to
Arch
Loading thread data ...

Nope, pulling cuts may give less control, making it more likely, but an edge is an edge.

Better to say scraping is cutting greater than perhaps 30 degrees off perpendicular to fiber direction.

That's why legal serpents want jury trials alright.

Especially if you're a turner and know where to look for the most common errors of commission or omisssion.

Who's the measure?

Or taken off. That's called "form."

Chatter tools? Carving tools? How about those who burn grooves rather than sanding?

Flattery will spoil most anything.

Only someone who fancies h/er/imself an artist would say that. Covers a multitude of mistakes by implying intent.

Folks seldom see the technique, only the result. Can you say "sandpaper?"

Flap the wings, toot the flute.

Might as well be valid in turning as in flat work. Unless you're an artist, and can make your own rules....

Reply to
George

Great list, Arch. I've spent several days trying to add to the list, but haven't come up with anything good.

Joe Fleming - San Diego

Arch wrote:

Reply to
Joe Fleming

Hi Arch

Mostly opinions I think Arch and not necessarily right or wrong, and the usual "depending on" and yes also a lot of BS is going around, We know don't we ;-)))

Have fun and take care Leo Van Der Loo

Arch wrote:

Reply to
l.vanderloo

InspirePoint website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.