I have tried sanding without sanding disks using regular sand paper. I have never been able to get a good finish with that technique. I have been turning bowls for about 2 and a half years and am having to do less sanding now than when I first started. But I still need to sand. Some people need to sand more than others. Some bowls need to be sanded more than others. Some woods need to be sanded more than others. Richard Raffin (I've seen him on video start with 60 grit and do a lot of sanding on the lathe) does more sanding than David Ellsworth (I took his class and he says he usually starts with 220 grit off the lathe). All I know is I need to sand while the lathe is turning and the grit I start with directly depends on many other factors.
I use an electric drill with the lathe off on some of the end grain problems. I also many times use the drill with courser grits while the lathe is moving at 500 rpm or slower to get rid of tool marks. I recently started using a passive sander (the Sorby brand) for the finer grits. The finish is better and I don't wear out the electric drill so fast.
I started out spending about 30 cents a piece for velcro disks at places like Woodcraft and Packards etc. Way too much. So I found a supplier that sold them for 20 cents a piece
formatting link
A bit better but still tomuch for me. As of now I am punching my own using the technique atthis web site...
formatting link
Now I amspending about 6 or 7 cents per velcro disk. I can live with that. The only draw back is that in order to save money using this techniqueyou must make a larger initial investment.Hope this helps, Ted