help with starter serger choice

Have a question or want to show off your project? Post it! No Registration Necessary.  Now with pictures!

Threaded View
Janome vs Brother vs White etc...


I am considering a Brother 1034d serger through Amazon...with discounts

and free shipping it's going to be $174.  I have never used a serger
before but I'm looking for a basic workhorse that I can use mostly for
finishing fabric.  I hand dye and quilt, so pre-washing commercial
fabric and multiple washes for hand dyes can leave me with a lot of
finish work from ironing to trimming threads.  When I finished the
edges (with a zigzag) on one load of commercial fabric, I didn't even
have to press it when it came out of the dryer.    I would also be
using the serger for fleece items and for making simple linens--pillow
cases, napkins, table runners, etc.

I posted my question to another group and it was suggested I post it
here.  Many in the other group had some suggestions for me and many
suggested BabyLock
Evolve (which I can't afford) or White. Another person suggested the
Gemsy G320. My local Joann's sells White and I can find it online.  I
found the Janome 204d for $239.99 with
free shipping at as suggested by one person.  I have a
Janome sewing machine so I'm partial to the brand but the Brother is
supposed to be easy to learn.

My question is--do you have any experience with the model of Brother
serger?--I've seen great reviews on the Amazon site.  Also it appears
to be discontinued by the way it's listed on the Brother
an older machine.  I'm not going to make a lot of clothing, and if that

changes, I think I can wait several years to upgrade.



Re: help with starter serger choice
 granite wrote:

Quoted text here. Click to load it

I can only suggest that you sit down and thread each one *before* making
up your mind.   Threading and differential feed are the most important
features for beginners IMO.  You also might want to consider who will
service your machine if you buy it thru Amazon.

I fear me you but warm the starved snake,
Who, cherished in your breasts, will sting your hearts. (Henry VI, Shakespeare)

Re: help with starter serger choice
I agree about threading one before you buy it. Elna's are easy to
thread and if you can get a 634 or a 714 in ebay you wlll love it.
After the babylock high enders that thread themselves, an elna is best
IMO... and I own three.

Re: help with starter serger choice

Quoted text here. Click to load it

NO!!!!!  Sorry to shout.  I had two Brother sergers.  Yes, two.  The first
one I had for a couple of days.  Then I had to take it back because, after I
stopped crying and realized it was not me, it would not work properly.  I
had the second one for much less time before it started doing the same thing
the first one did.  They both broke the thread at the lower looper.  There's
a "threader" that is supposed to make threading the lower looper easier.
Well, that's what was breaking the thread every time.  I can't remember the
number that was on that one, but I would avoid all Brother sergers like the

When I returned the second Brother serger, I went to Hancock's and got a
White.  I've had it now for several years.  It's just a basic serger,
nothing really fancy about it.  It's a White "Speedylock 234DE."  Now, if
you look for that at Hancock's, they won't have that exact model name.  Ask
the clerks if they've been there a few years and if so ask what the new
model name is for that one.  Basically the same machine is still available,
it's just called something else.  I really love mine.  And it gets A LOT of


Never try to teach a pig to sing.  It's a waste of time and just annoys the

Re: help with starter serger choice
Thank you, all.  I put the brakes on my purchase.  I'll call around and
see what's available through the local dealers.  Thanks again.


Re: help with starter serger choice
granite wrote:
Quoted text here. Click to load it

Buy a machine somewhere where you can get sewing help and technical
help.  The best Amazon can do is sell you a book!


Re: help with starter serger choice
Yarn Forward wrote:
Quoted text here. Click to load it

I have a Janome 344D that I got from a dealer and love it. I've done far
more sewing since I bought it than I ever did before. I'm not pushing
that machine but rather pushing buying from a dealer. I had some minor
problems that I couldn't work out, brought it back to the dealer and she
solved them. There was no charge involved, just a lot of her time. Not
all dealers will be that helpful, some or even most may charge for time
but all Amazon can do is, as Roger said, tell you to buy a book.

Site Timeline