Calculate the cost of baking

Jun 25, 2025 Last reply: 2 months ago 5 Replies

These prices are the lowest in my neighborhood (Boston area) on a weekly basis, mostly from Market Basket. They do not include sale prices or any marked-down goods I might find on the discount rack. Of course, I believe in stocking up when there IS a sale, but not everyone wants to have large amounts of butter, yeast or soy flour taking up space in the freezer. (Butter goes on sale maybe 3 times a year, where I live.)



The Tightwad Gazette chart (created by Amy Dacyczyn) had: price per pound, weight per cup, price per cup, price per tablespoon, and price per teaspoon. To save time, I'm only listing the price per cup or tablespoon (sometimes rounded up or down). If it doesn't say "Tb," then it means the price per cup. The main purpose is to allow you to compare made-from-scratch foods with each other.



If you use soy flour/powder and powdered milk in a pancake mix, you can add water instead of milk. (Soy powder and water can be used instead of eggs - but NOT in cookies or in many cakes!)



Baking powder 12 cents (Tb) Baking soda 2.4 (Tb) Brown sugar 59 Butter $1.99 Cocoa powder 8 (Tb) Coconut 35.5 Cornmeal 47 Cornstarch 37 (Tb) Honey $3 Imitation vanilla 7 (Tb) Liquid milk 16 Margarine 62.5 Molasses $1.75 Oats 38 Powdered milk 9 (Tb) Powdered sugar 34 Raisins 90 Salt 2 (Tb) Soy flour 11 (Tb) Vanilla 94 (Tb) Vegetable oil: 59 Wheat flour 33 White flour 22.5 White sugar 43.5 Yeast 19.5 (Tb)



And here are the weights per cup.



In ounces:



Baking powder 8 Baking soda 8 Brown sugar 7 Butter 8 Cocoa 4 Coconut 2 Cornmeal 6 Cornstarch 5 Cream of tartar 8 Honey 12 Imitation vanilla 8 Liquid skim milk 8 Margarine 8 Molasses 12 Oatmeal 4 Powdered milk 4.5 Powdered sugar 4 Raisins 4 Salt 10 Soy flour 4 Vanilla 6.75 Vegetable oil: 8 Wheat flour 4.5 White flour 6 White sugar 8 Yeast 5


Btw, when I posted this at rec.food.cooking in April, I made a few errors - but I've straightened them out.



And, of course, meals made from scratch - or plain fruit - tend to be cheaper per ounce than cold cereals or most processed foods. Leaving aside anything made with eggs - sometimes.


Very interesting, thank you. Are these all "lowest cost regardless of quality" or "lowest cost you'd want to go and still taste OK"?

Peter

Actually, I was simply referring to the fact that when it comes to baking ingredients, Market Basket (aka DeMoula's) is the cheapest supermarket around here.

I CAN say that I've never seen any difference in quality when it comes to their products vs Star (Shaw's).

Hi Peter, recently we've had to buy bread for the first time in ages. Reason is I'm mid-way through cataract surgery. Left eye done 18Jul, righteye this morning.

If you are very near and far sighted (coke bottle glasses), the adjustment is more radical. Equilibrium thown off and all that. Distance judging messed up. Bakingwent by the wayside as the Doctor doesn't want to chance a yeast infection in the eyes until well healed. Sensible sounding to me.

I hadn't really looked close at the cost of a loaf in years except my random jewish rye.

I find it 4$ a loaf for anything reasonably decent. Cheapest is 2.78 last trip. Compare this to making your own and that has gone up, but only by about 4% in the last 2 years.

Labor and transport seem the main drivers of store bought going up so much. Your markup now is officially 4X the cost to make it at home. It was twice the cost for ages though.

That goes without saying. Posting to rec.food.cooking is in itself an error.

This is pretty nice but doesn't have much bearing on my shopping. We don't have any of those. We have Trader Joe's, Harmon's, Whole Foods, Kroeger's, and Sprouts. My point is that those brands are very regional and I don't think you even mentioned what region you are from.

Not to be critical. Around here I'm more about quality than price, and I have these rankings

Whole Foods = Sprouts and both > Kroeger's Harmon's > Kroeger's

On the other hand I don't think you can beat Kroeger's prices once you obtain one of their rewards cards.

For example, a jar of Kroeger's lightly salted peanuts is more than a meal and costs under three dollars. For those of us who still have our teeth.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required