The Quest for the Healthiest Chocolate Chip Cookie

I have been on a quest to try and make the healthiest possible chocolate
chip cookie because... well, because I love home baked chocolate chip
cookies and it would be great if there was a way to make them so they
were less of an offending opposition to my goal to lose a few pounds.
Ridiculous quest? Perhaps. If you want to bake COOKIES you're clearly
not thinking HEALTHY (you're thinking TASTY) but there is still the idea
of the lesser of two evils (just an expression... cookies aren't evil).
Alright so I've been experimenting swapping out certain ingredients in
cookie recipes and I am getting close. The first attempt was a disaster
and produced perhaps the WORSTE cookies ever made by man.
Cardboard/styrofoam with no flavor. I almost gave up but then I realized
I didn't use enough of a very important ingredient... the butter. You
have to use so much of it!!!!! Oh well. That's the reality. So, I tried
again with the right amount of everything according to a recipe I read
on the back of a Splenda Brown Sugar bag... came out pretty good! Here's
what I intended to use:
1 Cup of Whole Wheat Flour (instead of all purpose flour)
1 egg
half a table spoon each of Baking Powder and Baking Soda (can anyone
tell me what these things do exactly?)
half a teaspoon of vanilla extract
half a cup of Splenda Brown Sugar
half a cup of Smart Balance butter (healthier than regular butter... or
I would have used "I can't believe it's not butter"... except the name
is too long for my tastes - jk)
Sugar Free chocolate (need to find sugar free chocolate CHIPS).
Sliced Almonds (I LOVE nuts in cookies but I'm nuts)
I ended up ALMOST doing it with the above but I chickened out on the
flour and did half whole wheat and half all purpose... and I used
regular chocolate chips. But it came out really good! So the next time I
do it I will try the above.
What do you think? Any thoughts on this? Anything in this list that
looks like a bad idea for any reason? Any BETTER ideas for making the
healthiest GREAT TASTING cookie?
I'll post a picture of it on my Facebook page when I do it with the
above ingredients: 'Infinite Cookbook | Facebook'
formatting link

Here's a previous attempt with less healthy involved: 'Infinite
Cookbooks Fotos - Dave's Creative Cuisine | Facebook'
formatting link
(even slightly burnt but... I like themslightly burnt actually).
Reply to
I'm a newbie to this group, but cookies, and healthier cookies are a huge quest of mine as well. I've always loved cookies. They are, in my opinion, the perfect snack and treat. Anyway, I best not get started on my love of cookies too much, it would take far too long to go into it. Baking Powder and Baking Soda are leaveners. When they are mixed with liquids (and sometimes heat) they bubble and fizz, therefore "raising" whatever they're used in. I use whole wheat in everything anymore. I've used 1/2 to 1/3 in most drop cookies. The thing I can say about using it, is that whole wheat usually takes up more liquid. So you have to watch the consistency of your dough when experimenting. For the Chocolate Chip Cookie recipe I use, the cookies come out best when the final dough is slightly crumbly, but not dry. Then when you bake them, bake just until very lightly browned and slightly under-done in the center; then let them sit on the cookie sheet for a few minutes before removing to a rack to cool. This will give you a soft chewy cookie. For thin crisp cookies, use a wetter dough. Anyway, just a couple of thoughts
Reply to

Site Timeline Threads

  • I made these kouign-amann based off of allrecipes recipe at This might just be...
  • last posted in

    Baking Crafts

InspirePoint website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.