Finished the halibut sweater for my boyfriend, now I don't have a boyfriend

Nov 21, 2026 Last reply: 22 hours ago 5 Replies
Jump to replies (5)

So I finally cast off the halibut sweater I'd been knitting for my boyfriend, and a few days after I finished it he proposed. He's my fiance now, which honestly feels like the best possible ending to a project.



I made a couple of tweaks to the pattern since I was nervous about the fit. I shortened the neckline because I didn't want it ending up with a batwing look, and I reworked the sleeves to suit him better, skipping the decreases until the elbow. Those two changes made a big difference in how it sits on him.



Yarn was Cascade 220 in brown heather and natural heather, and the fish yoke came out exactly how I hoped. I'm still a bit giddy about the whole thing, the sweater and the ring both.


That title got me for a second, I was already scrolling down ready to give comfort and knitting advice, and then it turned into the happiest possible version of the sweater curse story. Huge congratulations to you both. My husband proposed a few years back and I still remember that giddy, floaty feeling, so I'm grinning at my screen for you.

Your photo is lovely, by the way. The brown heather with the cream fish yoke against that rocky shoreline is such a good combination, and I love that you covered your face with the fish emoji, very on theme. I knit my boyfriend a sweater back when we were first together and I was a nervous wreck the entire time, convinced I was weaving our doom into every row. I can only imagine the pressure with a full halibut yoke on the line. I'm so glad the shorter neckline and the reworked sleeves worked out for you, fit tweaks are scary to commit to but they clearly paid off here. Enjoy the engagement and the sweater, that's a double win in my book.

I have to admire that you just went ahead and knit the thing. I'm the superstitious one in my house: when I read about the curse early into dating my now-husband, I decided he would get exactly zero handknits from me until after the wedding, and I stuck to it. He spent years asking about a proper sweater and got nothing but store-bought. You cast on anyway, adjusted the neckline and sleeves to actually fit him before you'd even finished, and came out engaged. Meanwhile I'm still knitting scarves for myself as some kind of protection charm, which is frankly less brave. Your photo is lovely too, that rocky shoreline with the flat grey water behind him suits the natural heather fish perfectly. One thing I'd love to know, since the fit worked out so well: when you redid the sleeves, were you working top down or bottom up? I've got a colourwork yoke of my own on the needles right now and the chart is tempting me toward something fishy, so any fitting wisdom is welcome.

I keep rereading the part where you shortened the neckline to avoid a batwing look, because that is exactly the failure mode I picture with a wide pictorial yoke, where the whole thing slides off the shoulder and sags instead of sitting flat. Did you take out depth at the yoke itself, or just pull the ribbing up shorter? I ask because I frogged the neckline on a colorwork yoke sweater of mine twice over a similar worry. Also, skipping the sleeve decreases until the elbow is a bold call, and honestly the way the sleeves hang in your photo makes it look like the right one.

I'm side-eyeing the idea that shortening the neckline is what stops a wide yoke from sliding off the shoulder. On my own colorwork yoke the sagging came from the yoke being too deep, not from where the ribbing sat, so pulling the ribbing up just made the fish bunch instead of fix anything. I keep wondering if the batwing look people blame on the neckline is really a yoke depth problem wearing a disguise. That's probably why I'd want to know if you took depth out of the yoke itself, because to my eye that's the only change that actually moves where the pattern sits on the body.

The sleeve change is what caught my eye. I made a men's yoke sweater for my husband last winter and left the sleeve decreases exactly as written, and he spent the whole season complaining that the forearm felt tight over his watch. Skipping the decreases til the elbow the way you did seems like the obvious fix in hindsight, but I never would have thought to deviate from the pattern like that. Did he have big forearms, or was it more just a general fit preference for a straighter sleeve? Also, brown heather was a smart call for a guy who might actually wear the thing, my husband's grey one gets way more wear than my colourful ones do.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required