New punch needler - need help deciding

Hi all,

Hoping you can help me. I haven't done punch needle before, but have conquered knitting with 4mm needles and 20mm; crochet; long-stitch; cross stitch and latch-hooking. I'm 25 and disabled so am certainly looking for a new hobby in front of the TV every night. In Australia it's VERY cold at the moment so having a cosy hobby would be nice. I'm wanting to do traditional punch needling -- not Russian or Bunka, whatever those are.

I've read up some and have a good idea what I want to do, but am confronted by the issue of what needle would best suit what I want to do. The choices are the Cameo 3 set or the Luxor 5 set -- or any other that one of you may recommend.

I'd like to make punch embroideries in polyester cotton (sewing cotton), acrylic yarn (for punch needling) and up to 5mm ribbon. At the same time, I want my stitch length to have variables. I'm wanting to do flat and textured designs and images.

How is the stitch length changed on the Luxor 5-sets? How many lengths are there? I noticed on the Cameo that it has 12 settings. Is it worth having the 12, or is 6 enough?

If I buy the Luxor 5-set, will the largest needle be big enough for

3-5mm ribbon?

The brands I'm looking at are: Cameo Luxor Purr-Fect Pretty Punch Dee Lite O-so-Ezy Super Luxo (Manual models. I want to do all the work for myself!)

I have already worked out what yarns, cottons, hoop, and designs I'd like to make, but would like help in solving this important query. I rather get it right the first time and not have to buy another.

Thanks for any help in advance,

Miss. S. BG.

Reply to
Season BubbleGirl
Loading thread data ...

Snipped rest for brevity.

Welcome to RCTN. After a couple of days, I haven't noticed anyone responding to your post. We have a few people here who punch needle. I think the terms Russian or Bunka mean the same thing and is what you want to try. But you may know of something new/old of which I'm unaware.

My suggestion to you is to contact the source (e.g. Cameo), or a retailer that handles them (they usually know their product), and see if you can get some answers.

Best of luck! I hope you keep us up-to-date on your needlework adventures.

Dianne

Reply to
Dianne Lewandowski

Season BubbleGirl said

I've only used "Russian" punchneedles so I can't comment on the brands you listed or whether or not they can handle ribbons. However, I will tell you to stock up on extra threaders and weaver's cloth or a reasonable facsimile. I'll leave it to someone who's more knowledgeable than I am about cloth to educate us both about possible facsimiles ;-)

Reply to
anne

InspirePoint website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.