OT A Christmas Carol Rant

Dec 03, 2007 21 Replies

OK -- one of my most favouritest Christmas carols is "Mary's Boy Child". But -- and this seems to be a BIG "but" (not at all related to MY butt which, by the way, IS big) -- anywhoo the BUT part is that I like the calypso version of the song. I know that Boney M and The Brothers Four recorded it in the calypso style (I'm not sure if it was written this way or not) but every time I hear it, it's one of those dreary, s l o w ballad versions. I mean, even Harry Belafonte recorded a boringly slow version of the song and the man WAS Calypso before any of us knew what that was -- the man is the reason us oldsters even know what calypso is for heaven's sake. Anyway, I want the up-beat, "jouncy" calypso version not another ballad. Sheesh -- there are umpty million ballad Christmas carols &/or songs out there but not very many calypso type carols. VBS and yes, I own the Boney M version but only on 45 rpm and I don't even have a turntable that works anymore :-(. Let it be known that there is NO ROOM for discussion about this. The calypso version is the best and those other treacley, smarmy, boringly slow versions should just be deleted from the offerings of the local radio stations AND the stuff AO(HEL)L offers !!!!! CiaoMeow >^;;^<



PAX, Tia Mary >^;;^< (RCTQ Queen of Kitties) Angels can't show their wings on earth but nothing was ever said about their whiskers! Visit my Photo albums at

formatting link


There's a much newer (to me) carol, called "The Calypso Carol", which I love, and which I've also heard played in church more like a dirge! It starts "See Him lying on a bed of straw, in a stable with an open door"

Joyce > > OK -- one of my most favouritest Christmas carols is "Mary's Boy

Try this - it's the youtube version by Boney M!

formatting link

Wow - both versions !! Thank you!! Just in case someone is counting, I like the joyous, toe-tapping version.

mag

That particular one isn't available, but you can find all sorts of good music at CyberHymnal.org

I've heard a recent version that was quite lovely:

formatting link
girl who sings it is only about 14 or 15 y.o., IIRC. sue

Great find Karen - thank you.... A good site to bookmark...

mag

You can find nearly anything there.

I'll worry when I find my son's "music" videos...

C

hmmmmm hummmm no it won't work!

RD&H

Gill

Ok, I've decided that THIS ONE is my favorite:

formatting link

I don't know what it is with church organists. One of ours, when we had a choir party, could even manage to make Happy Birthday sound dirge-like. FerPeteSake, we were teenagers, wasn't like someone was turning 40 and dirge was appropriate.

Thank Google. I was looking for something last night and they suggested this site. I was tickled.

Ummm, why would dirge be appropriate for turning 40? I don't get it when people think that getting older is a bad thing. I'm concerned that I'm about to be 45 and haven't accomplished certain goals, but I'll punch anybody who tries to play a dirge for me. I'm much happier at 45 than I was at 35 or 25, and goddess knows 15 was the pits!

Elizabeth

You`re dead right there! I LOVE the Boney M one!

Pat

Same reason, I suppose, that you so often hear hymns sung in such a doleful manner. Many of them are best sung very upbeat - there are some wonderful tunes which are totally ruined by being played slowly (Reverently doesn`t mean SLOWLY!)

pAT

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required