OT: Pennsylvanian killings

Oct 02, 2006 42 Replies

Of all the people to suffer the dreadful killings just described on our news tonight, the Amish must be the least likely. What a terrible, terrible event.



Pat


I agree completely. I am sure I dont need to say any more; rctners already know my feelings on this subject.

And for it to be the children, and little girls lined up against the blackboard and executed. It defies understanding.

It's no secret how I feel about guns and, of course, it's horrible that children have been killed.

Maybe it's a bad time to bring this up but the Amish aren't the peaceful people they're noted to be. It's a very well known and sad fact that the Amish run a large proportion of the puppy mills in the United States that are known to breed dogs under terrible conditions. They breed the dogs indiscriminately and send sick puppies to a lot of the pet shops. They're always being shut down by authorities, just to open up again in a short time.

Here's the first link I got when I googled Amish puppy mills

formatting link
was the first one listed of 90,900 articles. Makes you think twice about how gentle the Amish are, doesn't it?

And the feelings of the wife & children of the killer must be indescribable

I don't think any group of humans could ever be blameless, totally blameless.

I've seen and read things I didn't like about the Amish as well.

But again, as I wrote earlier, to line little girls up in front of a blackboard to execute them -- I still say that defies understanding.

It has been reported that he picked that school specifically because it was easiest to get into. Any non-Amish school would have metal detectors and security people milling about.

Words can't describe my feelings about that. To lose a child is in my mind the absolute worst thing that can happen to a human being and nothing can compare to that.

Lucille

"Lucille" ,in rec.crafts.textiles.needleworkwrote: and entertained us with

I had heard that locally when puppy mills were brought up in a thread. The shooting is a terrible thing, on our news they painted a picture of a man who was a total fruitcake, so it's not likely we can sort out what he was thinking. He apparently took his own kids to school, then went on to the Amish School.

Yes, Lucille, I would say this is a bad time to bring this up.

Felice

That may be so, but is hardly relevant to this sad event. Yes it IS a bad time to bring it up.

Pat

"Felice Friese" ,in rec.crafts.textiles.needleworkwrote: and entertained us with

Why would that be ? The statement was made that set the Amish as being a surprising place for this to happen. It isn't and apart from puppy mills, didn't we have quite a long thread on here a few months ago about how they sell quilts stitched by little third world persons for Amish stitched prices.

Now I am not saying and I would not believe for a moment Lucille was either, that those two things justify anything that happened today, but let's not perpetuate the idea of gentle Amish, quaintly from another era. It isn't so.

We were all horrified to see that evil event , for a long time now i think the world is back to the dark ages. in many aspects, mirjam

Um. Not true about non-Amish schools. I've been googling around trying to a find a source for the statistics that Good Morning America showed, but haven't found what I'm looking for. They asserted that only 6% of schools have metal detectors and less than 50% of schools have full-time security people.

I know from personal experience that any school that my childlren attended (starting in 1993 through today), could be easily entered by anyone.

Donna in Virginia

First of all, I'm not English, I'm American.

Second, I wouldn't buy a puppy from a pet shop because of this problem.

Lucille

English is what the Old Order Amish call us Americans.

And good for you for not buying from a breeder.

Now, lay off the Amish. They didn't br>>Oh please. There wouldn't be puppy mills if us "English" didn't buy them. > >

Funny, seems like a YMMV issue because I know I couldn't get 5 steps past the lobby with out being challenged in any of the local schools. And there is police officer full time at both the high school and the middle school and maybe even the north most elementary school.

Cheryl

Again you've got me wrong.

One, I said I wouldn't buy from a pet shop and would only buy from a breeder.

Two, I have more sympathy than you could imagine for the horror of losing these little, innocent kids.

Feeling horror about the terrible murders of the children doesn't change my sadness at the fact that the Amish aren't as innocent as people think they are or my belief that no one should own a gun

Lucille.

then shame on you for buying from a breeder. too many innocent dogs and cats dying in spca's and humane societies because you think that a purebreed is the only way to go. shame shame shame.

and shame > Again you've got me wrong.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required