Book review "Hobo Quilts"

Sorry, but I can not recommend that you purchase "Hobo Quilts" unless you are willing to calculate how to make the blocks yourself. Please read on.

Hobo Quilts by Debra G. Henninger is the fourth in a series by Krause Publications which combines historical writings with sampler quilt block patterns. The first two books were by Rosemary Youngs and contained quotes from dairies and letters written during the Civil War. Each quote was accompanied by a quilt block. The blocks had nothing to do with the quote but the combination was interesting. The books sold very well both to those interested in Civil War history and to quilters. The books had line drawings of the quilt blocks but no instructions. Rosemary sold a companion CD which had to be used in conjunction with Electric Quilt to produce templates or foundation drawings.

The third book was "Farmer's Wife" by Laurie Aaron Hird. The written text was exerts from letters written in the 1930's answering the question, "Knowing your life as a farmer's wife would you recommend that your daughter marry a farmer?" The text was very interesting if you are at all connected to farming. The format of the book was the same as the first two but a CD was included which printed templates only. You could not change the size of the blocks or print foundation drawings. Many of the CD's were damaged in shipment. Just this month a companion CD has been released which runs in conjunction with Electric Quilt. Now for an additional $20 you can print templates or foundation drawings in any size.

Because I had enjoyed the first three books I eagerly bought "Hobo Quilts" the day it arrived at the store. The blocks are not your typical sampler quilt blocks. Each block graphically reproduces one of the symbols in the secret language of riding the rails. This is the way hobos communicated with anyone traveling behind them. The symbols would tell them if they would receive food at a certain house, if this was a good place to camp or if the local sheriff would run all hobos out of town. The quotes are from actual hobos writing about their experiences riding the rails prior to 1940. Many photos of the period are also included creating a very interesting book. The blocks are again given as line drawings but under each drawing is listed the size pieces which are needed to make the block. If the block is to be appliqued that is noted under the drawing and you are instructed to trace the line drawing. I thought the addition of the piece sizes was great until I started to make the blocks. The sizes on many of the blocks are wrong. The pieces don't fit together or if they do the block is not the correct size when you are finished. I have emailed the publisher and will report back when I hear from them.

Until this pattern situation is solved I would not recommend that you purchase "Hobo Quilts".

Susan Price

Reply to
Susan Laity Price
Loading thread data ...

Thank you, Susan. The books sound both very interesting and annoying. So glad you've warned us about the quilt block trauma. Polly

"Susan Laity Price" Sorry, but I can not recommend that you purchase "Hobo Quilts" unless

Reply to
Polly Esther

I greatly appreciate your comments. Not that I'm going to launch into another project like this now, but for future reference. joan

Reply to
joan8904 in Bellevue Nebraska

Thank you for your review, Susan. I might add that the "mother" of these books was "Dear Jane" by Brenda Papadakis, which has only line drawings of each block - a CD was later added, allowing the quilter to print templates, resize, etc. Rosemary was an early member of the online DJ community.

Like you, I enjoy books like these which have a little bit of history

- letters, diaries - also authors like Barbara Brackman who do extensive research into the Civil War era in the US and its connection with quilting.

Unlike many new quilters who prefer a detailed pattern with cutting directions, I don't mind working with a "life-size" line drawing. I was annoyed that "The Farmer's Wife Sampler Quilt" did not even show that. All the originally included CD did was print out templates, one to a page (what a waste of paper!)

Another book I bought about the same time as FWSQ was "Sylvia's Bridal Sampler" by Jennifer Chiaverini. This book doesn't have the historical connection as the others, but has excellent directions for 140 six- inch sampler blocks. There are rotary cutting directions, plus 40 pages of templates and paper-piecing foundations. You don't have to be a follower of Jennifer's Elm Creek series of novels to appreciate this book.

Ginny, enjoying my school vacation week - I will actually spend part of Earth Day digging in the garden

Because I had enjoyed the first three books I eagerly bought "Hobo Quilts" the day it arrived at the store.

Reply to
ginny

Susan, when Rosemary Youngs' first book (Civil War Diary) came out she started a yahoo group for it. She paper pieced all the blocks, so it was a straight out print a copy of the block to make it. I started supplying rotary cutting instructions for the blocks. But ran out of steam part way through. Many of those blocks had odd divisions that were very difficult to make with rotary cutting. (they are 6" finished blocks, but many are done on a 5x5 grid. So the "unit size" is 1 1/5 inch. not easy to measure.) I think I got Civil War Love Letters, but haven't even looked at it much.

I like reading these types of books, but making the blocks may be more than I want to do.

In some cases I tend to redraft the blocks to fit better.

Sounds like Hobo Quilts is the same way. A good read, but not a good pattern book.

Pati, in Phx

Reply to
Pati, in Phx

InspirePoint website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.