Among woodturners these days there's a lot of wringing of hands and gnashing of teeth about stealing ideas from mother nature, antiquity and each other. We on rcw have remained relatively quiet, but we have issues too. Don't we have the same right to weep, wail, agonize and deplore these awful crimes?
I think so and I'm gonna exercise my right.
Established turners have their protective cliques to provide security. Turners just coming into their own have their protective claques to provide mutual praise and thanksgiving. Beginners who pose no threat and have naught to protect are welcomed and urged to turn onward and upward.
Just you remember Mr Beginner, not to sell anything that resembles a turning that somebody posted on a net forum or published and republished ad nauseum in magazines or DVDs, even if it was once openly and proudly displayed in some club's instant gallery. Certainly you better remember not to sell something that you paid someone to teach you how to turn.
What about my group? Those of us whose innovative minds and creative artistry originated the tacky bowl and ugly candle stick. We are sick & tired of being copied just because the public bought and used our miserable originals in happy ignorance for years. Our awful work has been copied and plagiarized all too often and it hurts. You people who copy our bad work and make even worse derivitives know who you are and you ought to be ashamed.
I forgot to copyright my original ugly bowl and awful candle stick and even though they were my originals, now hundreds of turners are turning ugly and awful work every day. Some are even uglier and sell better than mine, but tacky, ugly and awful is easily recognized as a copy of an original 'Arch'. Even if my work was the first to be awful, the plagiary is clearly obvious and it's just not fair.
I, along with my fellow wallowers in unceasing plagiary postings echo the words of the old song, "There, I've said it again" .....and I suspect that we'll say it again and again and ....and again!
As usual, I am mistaken and my subject line is in error. I'm not honestly and truly sick & tired of discussing plagiarism. Like a few others I heard of, I really wanted to bring it up and moan about it one more time. Next week I hope to revisit "art vs craft" in some depth. I know it's hard to wait, but please try to be patient and I'll reward you later with a thorough and unabridged review of "freehand versus sharpening jigs". Oh, the joys of an uncensored forum! :)
Turn to Safety, Arch Fortiter