Joe, this is an extremely interesting thread that you started, albeit discussed often. I was going to respond but Robert (nailshooter) keeps expressing my opinion before I can! : )
I'm with you and Robert on every point. Turn for fun. If a piece begs to be held, fondled and or used, it's the BEST art anyone can ask for.
I totally agree that inspiration comes to different people in different ways because of their brain (good with math, good with hand skills), environment (raised with artwork, farm, mechanical), past memories (old spoons, old bowls) or training (art school, retired engineer). When I look at a piece of wood, I see a piece of wood that would be fun to turn.
abounds and inspiration flows like Niagra Falls.
It's all be done before, we just can't copy that good and thus create individual style.
Enjoy (key word)
Ruth