1. Home
  2. Woodturning Crafts
  3. Review of Benjamin's Best

Review of Benjamin's Best

I got a 5/8" bowl gouge. It cost $20 plus not including shipping. The handle is ok lengthwise for me but smaller in diameter than my other bowl gouges. The shaft length is 9 inches but the usable flute length is only 3 3/4 inches. In comparison, my new Packard bowl gouge has a shaft length of 9 3/4 and a usable flute length of 5 3/4.

My biggest complaint is the flute itself. It is straight sided--nearly a v-shape. When used head on, the cutting width is narrow. It works ok when cutting with the wings but there is minimal transition between a straight wing cut and a v cut. Similar to having a right and a left narrow skew chisels joined together.

So, to me, it is worth about what it cost.

Reply to
Gerald Ross
Loading thread data ...

I must have smaller hands than I thought.. ;~]

Might depend on the grind and how it's used? I do a pretty aggressive sweep and don't use the tip/point, so they seem fine to me.. I just ordered 2 more plus a 1" roughing gouge... I'll grind 1 swept and the other more a conventional fingernail and see how it works..

mac

Please remove splinters before emailing

Reply to
mac davis

I have one V shaped gouge, and find it works better on the outside of the bowl than it does on the inside. Also if I get agressive with it, it does clog up some times. I do prefer the U shaped gouges as being better at all purpose cutting. The gouges by Doug Thompson are in my opinion the best ones out there, They are one of the 'lasts 5 times longer' gouges that do actually keep their edges longer than anything else I have used. Their U shaped gouge is very broad, almost like a spindle gouge, and their V shaped gouge is slightly wider than most of the other V shaped gouges I have seen. They are sold unhandled.

robo hippy

e:

Reply to
robo hippy

InspirePoint website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.