In case any of y'all were wondering

Those of you who haven't encountered "recycled sari silk" yarn might be interested in this review:

I swapped some good wool (which I knew I'd never use) for about twice as much "recycled sari silk" yarn. This should have thrown up a warning flag - the person I swapped with was willing to give me about

3x the value of the wool. Granted, it was nice wool but didn't have the cash value of the silk yarn.

So, it gets here. My swapmate has wound it into cakes. Great, less work for me. I opened the zippy to fondle the yarn and was just about knocked out by the reek - not smoke, not dog, just reekage. Sizing, the smell of wet lint, and something gross that wasn't poo or anything else I could identify.

I let the stuff air out until I had to put my nose into a cake to find the stink and started swatching. The stuff is grossly overspun hard yarn containing bits of hay, bits of cotton string, and gods only know what else. Obviously the stuff was made from the sweepings of the cutting room floor!

Today I rehanked it all and put it through the wash.

Twice.

On hot/hot/hot with a second rinse both times and with GOBS of stinky shampoo I keep around for company, and plenty of agitation. Silk won't full and I wasn't gentle with it. The water turned black and that end of the house still has about it a miasma that makes me slightly nauseous when I go down there.

The yarn is right now in the dryer. [Don't panic. Silk doesn't full, and I tied all the hanks securely.] It is perhaps not so stinky now, and will perhaps be softer and easier to knit after the abuse of being washed with much agitation and being dried on high heat. If not I will attempt to get some of the twist out by running it through one of my spinning wheels.

Here's a photo of the first wash. The second wash-with-soap was no better, but the last rinse was only slightly dye- and dirt-tinged. I'm running a load of random white towels with plenty of bleach and hoping I didn't ruin my washer ;P

formatting link
not horribly huge for dialup users)+++++++++++++

Reply to the list as I do not publish an email address to USENET. This practice has cut my spam by more than 95%. Of course, I did have to abandon a perfectly good email account...

Reply to
Wooly
Loading thread data ...

I bought a hank of that recycled sari silk a little while back and crocheted a lovely little purse for myself. I did find it pricey, and it knotted like all hell, but it felt and smelled wonderfully exotic. And in the new bead store here, they have smaller hanks of it that seems even nicer than what I had (didn't buy any; used my cash to treat my children to lunch out). I did find the occasional bit of stiff stuff that resembled hay, but nothing that I couldn't pick off easily. Did I mention that it knotted like all hell? And tangled every stitch or two?

Perhaps the smaller stores I can access here have sourced a different brand/quality? Or perhaps your swapmate unfortunately found an inferior hank? I've heard that there are differing grades of the recycled sari silk; craft being one that is apparently inferior to knitting/garment grade. My LYS couldn't confirm this, though.

My sympathies on the ordeal....

Michelle

Reply to
Eastern Edge

Hi Wooly,

I treated myself to some of that yarn a couple of years ago for Mother's Day. It was smelly too, but not so bad as yours sounds. For me the worst thing was that it went from being absurdly thick to frighteningly thin (1 little thread). I was sure the stuff would break. Also, it knits up really heavy, so I wouldn't make a sweater out of it. I did make a scarf that went bad. My fault, not the yarn's. I was facinated with how it was made and the weird "hand" of it, but I probably wouldn't use it again. I never thought of washing it before I used it. I'd like to know how that works out.

Hesira

Reply to
hesira

Hi Wooly,

I treated myself to some of that yarn a couple of years ago for Mother's Day. It was smelly too, but not so bad as yours sounds. For me the worst thing was that it went from being absurdly thick to frighteningly thin (1 little thread). I was sure the stuff would break. Also, it knits up really heavy, so I wouldn't make a sweater out of it. I did make a scarf that went bad. My fault, not the yarn's. I was facinated with how it was made and the weird "hand" of it, but I probably wouldn't use it again. I never thought of washing it before I used it. I'd like to know how that works out.

Hesira

Reply to
hesira

In article , Wooly wrote:

Hello Wooly:

As I just mentioned in a previous posting, I have bought a plastic zipped see through bag of recycled silk sari threads, 11"x8"x5" On the bag it states that these are 100% silk fiber from recycled mill ends of silk cloth used in the making of Saris. It comes from Nepal as part of a community outreach program. My silk also smells. I would say it is plain good old sweat, as well as some milling oils and dyes smells, and also the smell of silk gum. No it is not a pleasant smell, but it is nothing that you can't get rid of though. Silk is supper strong. Also we do talk about recycled silk. Silk of used saries, and keep in mind that (at least mine does), it comes from one of the poorest countries in the world. No soap, no deodorants. We have a foster child in Nepal, and she and her family ( Mother father, and 5 kids) live in a one room house. No toilet, no running water, a small fire on the floor for cooking and warmth. I guess it is a huge culture chasm and hard for most of us to imagine what that is like. I paid for my bag $40 Canadian dollars. I love the colours and also that these were worn by women, just like me, I feel some kinship. Also there is an helping out, as well as buying something you love and want to work with. I have also bought the skeins. They were also not all that clean, but again I washed them and knitted and crochetted with them and the smell disappeared with the use of some hot water, and soap. I have a feeling that whoever traded with you was not trying to deceive you, I think she was passing on what she had bought as it comes from the coop.

I hope to have a lot of fun with this, and will let you all know how I make out, smell and all....LOL

Els

Reply to
Els van Dam

Wooly, I see your frustration! I didn't understand what the picture was, at first!!!

I remember I did a little search about Sari silk, I hadn't heard about it earlier, and thought it would be lovely to get some. Then I read that "there is Sari silk - - - and there is Sari silk..." The quality differ highly, and you should be sure what quality you will get, some are very stiff with lots og hamp-like bits, and some are softer and thinner and much better to work with. As I most likely had to order it from "Over-The -Pond", I found out it wasn't worth it, as long as I could see it with my own eyes befor buying. Sorry to hear you are disappointed, But I know you don't give in easyly, so I look forward to hear the end of the story! ;-)) AUD ;-))

"Wooly" skrev i melding news: snipped-for-privacy@4ax.com...

Reply to
Aud

Hi Aud!

There is a shop in Stockholm (maybe more than one) carrying sary silk yarn. I bought there some sary acril yarn (very similar but not so expensive) and it wasn't dirty at all. Maybe the difference was that it came from worn out sari and not from sari farm junk, who knows. Anyway, I wonder about the working conditions of people making the yarn Wooly got, GOSH!

Hugs,

Anna Maria

Aud wrote:

Reply to
Anna MCM

Thank you wooly for this post ,, when i bought [ several years ago]an old Sari and used the Good parts to make a festive skirt +jacket , i had a very nasty smell from it .... since it has loads odf silver threads in it, i was reluctant to wash it , but just as well reluctant to give for dry cleaning ,,,, thus i aired it [ out side in well windy but no sun place .... than i slightly washed it with shampoo ,,, than i closed it in a bag , added good smelling parfums and squezed the air out of it ,,,, left it thus for a MONTH ,,,, when it came out it never reeeked again ??? have no answer to why and how ???? mirjam

Reply to
Mirjam Bruck-Cohen

OMG Wooly, sounds awful, you may have to un-spin it and spin it all again, you'd have done better to have had the raw silk...gosh..poor you, wouldn't fancy that job at all.

hugz cher

Reply to
spinninglilac

InspirePoint website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.