Performance ratings of Stand Mixers

Nov 05, 2005 3 Replies

The current issue, Nov/Dec 2005 (issue # 77) of Cook's Illustrated magazine has a great review of stand mixers. It's especially pertinent to bread makers since dough working was one of the tests. It's worth a look if you are in the market for a new or first mixer.

formatting link



The issue I have with Cook's Illustrated is that their criteria are often detached from reality. For instance, they picked an $80 All-Clad cake pan as their best choice over a list of fine pans. Everyone knows that stainless is a poor heat conductor. They said that cakes stuck to aluminum cake pans, including the brands that I use. I don't have a problem with cakes sticking to the pan, and therefore spending $80 on a stainless pan seems ridiculous. Furthermore, you are way out of luck if you want to make anything but a small round or square cake because All-Clad has an extremely limited line of pans.

BTW, membership is required to read articles online.

so go to the library or barnes and noble

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required