Turning ghosts, real or imagined?

The recent All Hallows Eve celebration got me to musing about woodturning ghosts and if they really exist. I've heard ghost stories about them, but I've never seen one lurking in the shadows of any turning studio-shop. This is not about the fuzz outlined on off-center blanks, it's about _invisible artisans who begin or finish the turned art of better known turners. Do these _invisible ghosts exist? If so, do they raise questions of ethics and authenticity? Do they endanger a fledgling art?

I emphasize 'invisible' because this is not about collaborations or occasional production runs in smaller shops or in similar situations where the assistance is 'up front' and usual. Interns 'close up' for prominent surgeons, bodies are 'added' to heads painted by elite portrait painters and designated hitters stand in for pitchers. Ghost writers are legion. I asume there's no ethical problem when assistence is openly proclaimed, but what about signing a piece of wood art that is finished by someone else or the form is a mere piece of canvas manufactured elsewhere?

I am no ethicist and I admit to being naive and uninformed re the rules of behavior in the art business; even more so in the emerging arena of turned wood art. That caveat aside, I think that openly acknowledging ghost turners is key to propriety and this elevates the practice of woodturning. What do you think?

Turn to Safety, Arch

Fortiter,

formatting link

Reply to
Arch
Loading thread data ...

If they're out there, they're more than welcome to come finish a few of my mediocre pieces. : )

steve

Reply to
Steve Wolfe

Thank you for your response Steve. I doubt that you would see nothing wrong in signing and marketing the pieces as your own work. I think that you are probably just being facetious and poking fun at my raising what very well may not be a problem for the future of turned wood art.

Actually, I had hoped my musing might merit some attention and attract some discussion. Like the old bodgers, my musings may have about run their course, but I hope you will follow up on your comment because I would really like to know how you feel about ghost turners. Thanks again.

Turn to Safety, Arch

Fortiter,

formatting link

Reply to
Arch

I carve the 'odd' woodspirit Arch and I'm sure my hands are 'guided' by those spirits. Now, if I could just find a medium with talent......

Tom

Reply to
Tom Storey

Yep, I'm just having fun. If one of the "ghosts" did, indeed finish a piece for me, then the problem (aside from the moral questions) would be the next time I was expected to perform to that caliber!

steve

Reply to
Steve Wolfe

holy twirling ectoplasm Batman!!! how did he ever mount that ghost to the faceplate? And check out those transparent shavings!!!! Bam! holy catch, he's outta here !!!!

>
Reply to
william_b_noble

A number of pros employ their spouses (or others) as sanders or in applying finish. Bet none of them list it as collaborative work, though.

Reply to
George

=========================

Arch, "Ghosts" may or may not be real, but I'm convinced that "gremlins come into my work area and play havoc with my perfection!

Ken Moon Webberville, TX

Reply to
Glynda Moon

My post was either too obtuse or too frivolous to be understood. Yep, it is the moral question that I was musing about. I thank you all for your comments, however the ghosts I had in mind are excellent but mostly unknown turners; journeymen that do some or most of the turning of work that's farmed out to them then signed and sold by a busy high profile wood artist as his/her original work. By 'finishing' I meant 'completing', not just sanding, oiling etc. a completed piece.

Have any of you competent turners ever been approached by a turning luminary to be his/her ghost turner in the same sense as a paid ghost writer? No names mentioned of course, but make no mistake it does happen. This practice may be acceptable and harmless. I just wondered if you thought it might impact the public's perception of woodturning as an emerging art.

Turn to Safety, Arch

Fortiter,

formatting link

Reply to
Arch

The old masters had their "studios" where the grunts and wannabes took away a lot of the marble or painted the backgrounds. We still call them artists.

Since art is a personal feeling, should cut both ways.

Reply to
George

Oh it was about *morals*. No wonder I didn't understand it; being one of the 49ers.

;)

Reply to
Owen Lowe

InspirePoint website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.