Turning Green (was I guess I'm confused)

[Note: this is the third time that I've posted this msg, which, apparently, is going no further than my local news server. This time I'm posting from Google, though, so you can all enjoy my purple(heart) prose.]

Those who learn from another tend to follow the

>prejudices of their teacher, whose technique may be the limiting factor >rather than the tool.

Boy, ain't that the truth! I have an acquaintance who claims to have been turning for many years. He has an older "mentor," however, with whom he spends most(all) of his turning time. He has managed to absorb virtually every prejudice, misconception, idiosyncracy and bad habit of his mentor.

The one that gets me the most, though, is his almost pathological hatred of turning anything other than kiln-dried lumber. This, of course, he picked up from his teacher, who has all sorts of pat excuses for his refusal to and indeed denigration of anybody who does turn green wood.

In all the years I've been reading this newsgroup and in the couple years I've been turning, I've never run into anybody like these two.

Does anybody else know of people who call themselves woodturners and loathe green wood?

Reply to
Chuck
Loading thread data ...

Hee, hee! I'm just the opposite. I dislike turning DRY wood.

Peter Teubel Milford, MA

formatting link

Reply to
Peter Teubel

My carving mentor made and sold thousands of pieces of treenware. Taught hundreds of people to carve those spoons and such - all with seasoned wood. First time I carved green at class and showed him how much easier it was, I asked him why he didn't carve green. He looked at me strangely and said "because I never really thought of it."

Then when I pulled out a spokeshave to do the main work on the handle, I caught the same look. He'd always used a jackknife....

Reply to
George

Traditionally, treenware was done green, and in the woods, too. Turners would build little huts in the woods for their pole lathes and turn until the nearby trees were gone then move their huts for the next season.

Reply to
Dan Bollinger

InspirePoint website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.