Our oldest dog doesn't even like toys... she used to play with (are you ready?) and old pair of sweatpants that we would play tug-of-war with, but she won't even touch regular doggy toys at all. Casper (my 4 year old baby) loves his toys... but he hates the squeakers, he cries while carrying them around... so I have to remove the squeaker before he's happy with them. The last couple I got were actually soft baby toys from the St Vincent de Paul store for a dollar. He doesn't destroy them, but every so often one of them will get a small tear and I have to sew it up. But his most favorite one is Santa Claus that was his first soft toy when he was a little guy of 5 months old. When you ask him at Christmas time "Where's Santa Claus?" he goes from his toy, to the stuffed one we hang on the wall, to the Santa candle, to even the lighted one in the window (which to my eye doesn't even have the right shape unless it is lit up and it's colors show). Matthew swears it's the colors, even though the *experts* say that animals are color-blind.
*shrug*Gem