Mad scientist Iron test results

Deep from within the secret location of a little know quilting test laboratory the results are in as to the vexing question,"How hot is this iron"? After extensive research (15 minutes) I have come to the conclusion that the printed range of the label on the two irons I inspected are wildly optimistic. The cheap dry iron set on it's hottest setting (linen) produced a high of 356 degrees(F). Placement of the digital probe was in as close to similar position as I could get. The B & D classic steam/dry iron set on dry registered 325 as the highest reading when set on the Linen or highest setting. The heat tended to drop from the highest to about almost 100 degrees lower between cycles of on and off. This may have been due to the material in the sole. Steel on the B & D and Aluminum on the dry iron. If anybody has a Rowenta that is working, sorry about that, they might try the experiment by using a digital thermometer and placing it between a block of wood and the sole of the iron. I placed the probe toward the front directly beneath the dial assuming that is where the thermostat is probably located on these irons. The conclusion I came to is that you probably get what you pay for in irons. Inconsistent heat that can be remedied by placing the setting on the highest point and hoping for the best, or spending over $400 on the only commercial Dry iron that I could find but that is claimed to having accurate thermostatic control. This concludes this test, and if anybody has any other irons they could duplicate this test on they can inform curious public desperate for further information as to the "True" heat range of the iron they have. Or even people who are casually interested in the readings and are happy with their irons. Inquiring minds are a terrible thing to waste, now back to quilting, (with a less than stellar performing iron).

John

Reply to
John
Loading thread data ...

And guess what -all this talk about irons, and my iron said "Humnph!" and died :-( All very sudden. It was working perfectly, and then .....not. On a weekend too, can't get a new one before Monday, and I was in the middle of a hot project!

Thanks for running the experiment. Now we know that cranked to the max isn't really very hot at all. Roberta in D

"John" schrieb im Newsbeitrag news: snipped-for-privacy@w28g2000hsf.googlegroups.com...

Reply to
Roberta Zollner

This made me smile ruefully! (not mirthfully, Roberta). We have a disastrous track record with kettles! Now we have started buying two at a time >g< We also keep a spare iron and vacuum cleaner (they work, just not very well!) . In message , Roberta Zollner writes

Reply to
Patti

I'm known for needing a new coffeepot every couple of years.

Reply to
KJ

I'd go thru a vacuum cleaner every 2 years. Even had one burn up--thankfully DH was home and threw it out into the garage before it burst into flames. Our house in B'splat had an in-house vacuum--and so does this one. This one needed a LOT of repair work but we got it fixed. They are so much easier to use...no lugging or pulling a machine as you work. (Even tho I'm still 'not allowed' to use it)

Butterfly

Reply to
Butterflywings

Good idea, I shall buy 2 irons this time. Roberta in D

"Patti" schrieb im Newsbeitrag news:$ snipped-for-privacy@quik.clara.co.uk...

Reply to
Roberta Zollner

Smile! . In message , Roberta Zollner writes

Reply to
Patti

Maybe thr old addage of he/she who dies with the biggest stash wins, should be amended to include irons also.

John

Reply to
John

Sorry, I just have to laugh that my original innocent question asking for iron recommendations sparked off such a possible-nobel-prize- winning-experiment! And all the related conversations. I've been checking this newsgroup while waiting for my B&D Classic to heat-up for another quilting session and I think it's probably ready...although it sounds like it might be a good 100 degrees less ready than I'm supposing! :-)

Reply to
PogoGirl

On Dec 8, 9:23 am, John wrote:

In further unscientific experimentation I decided to check the temp of my Steam Generator iron. It is a Euro-pro and I have been under the impression that steam generator irons were the cats pajamas as far as high heat. Well let disabuse you of that assumption. I was only able to get 325 degrees tops out of it. Now that makes two steam irons that are not as high as a cheap dry-flat iron. Then It dawned on me that that might not be as bad as it sounds. Why you ask? Well, by their very nature steam irons generate (ta-da!) steam. That softens the wrinkles on things that are being ironed and lets the hot iron of whatever temperature flatten the whole thing out. Now, dry irons need higher heat for the flattening process, so, In my humble opinion, that is why, of the three irons I have, the dry iron gets hotter. This, of course, could all be bunk, as all of the irons that I own might be junk, but they all do work in their own special way. Soooo. I'm happy and you should be too. That is if your irons do what you want them to do without spitting stuff and leaking all over the place. I do think that the settings on most irons are not accurate, so you probably should find the setting that works for you and disregard the posted setting on the iron. This finally and conclusively ends my experiment in this quest for knowledge, vis-a-vis the eternal question, "How hot is my Iron?" It has been a real roller-coaster ride of dedicated research and I am now happy it is over. But you know, I have been wondering, how sharp is my rotary cutter, really. Ah, to heck with it. Good night.

John

Reply to
John

oooppppsssss... I have a bunch of irons. All in various levels of workablity. I think I have 3 Rowenta Power Glide irons, (long stories, but all work, one really leaks, one sort of leaks and one is old and needs a serious cleaning because it quit getting as hot as I like it.) my steam generator, Grandma Milne's dry iron, one of the little tiny Clover "wand" irons, 2 small, look-like-regular iron craft irons, a Rowenta travel iron, and a Rowenta Steamer. Then there is the cordless iron that I delegated to DH who uses it in some way to transfer patterns for carving onto wood. I *think* that is all of them.

Pati, > Maybe thr old addage of he/she who dies with the biggest stash wins,

Reply to
Pati C.

Reply to
Patti

I'm sure you meant IG nobel prize winning experiments.

formatting link

--Lia

Reply to
Julia Altshuler

InspirePoint website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.