My nomination for the most useless discussions of 2006

I just can't watch any more football today, so I'll share my monotony and boredom with you all. I'll even add to it. The nature of turned wood art and in particular its relation to the craft of turning wood used up a lot of rcw bandwidth during '06 and we ended up at '07 where we started in '06. We asked ad nauseum and never got an answer to such useless questions as:

  1. What is art? Particularly turned wood art.

  1. Re turned wood, what is aesthetic experience? or something like that.

  2. Can the beauty inherent in a turning be truly objective or is it just in the eye of a beholder?

  1. Can turned wood art be seen and understood as something separate from the craft of woodturning? Who determines that? How do they do it?

  2. Can a woodturner be a good artist without mastering the craft?

  1. Can turned wood art have meaning? Does it depend on the turner's intentions? If not what does it depend on?

  2. Does a work of turned wood art need to resemble what it is about or is it better that it doesn't look like it or anything else?

8, What does all this stuff about representation, impression, expression. imagination, inspiration and satisfaction have to do with turning a piece of bird's eye maple on a Nova 3000?

  1. As a distinct group, do we woodturning craftsman/artists need to become known as a 'movement' (no bathroom humor please) or an academy like the 'Hudson River School' or the S.E. Fla. artists known as the 'Highwaymen', (They weren't criminals, they sold their folk art in stands along US I in Ft. Pierce and now their work is much sought after).

10 Blah! Blah! Blah! Can you think of any threads more useless that these? Maybe I'll just watch a little of the first half of the next game before I fall asleep. The fireworks will wake me up at midnight. :)

Turn to Safety, Arch Fortiter

formatting link

Reply to
Arch
Loading thread data ...

Good observation Arch. Of course that will not stop us bringing it up again. Fun is fun after all. Happy New Year my friend.

Reply to
Darrell Feltmate

Gee Arch its good to see you haven't lost your touch. I was beginning to wonder if you had given up on the musings. As usual very provocative and amusing Hoping for many more in 2007 Happy New Year you old curmudgeon! And to everyone else! Big 65 for me this year so I will get the time to seriously contemplate all these questions:-) Peter

Reply to
Canchippy

Arch, I think You started more than a few of these! :o)

Reply to
Lobby Dosser

InspirePoint website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.