Re: Star Muddle - A vote???

Yes, I think I like #3 as well- it seems to "pop" more than the others somehow. SueS

Kitty,

I like #1. It seems to "glow" more than the others -- almost like a real star.

I like either 1 or 3, the middle in #2 is too lost in similar values to show up.

Becky

Well, so far I'm in the minority! I like #2. The others have the focus in the center of the star, and this one is bigger visually. I like the subtle texture created in the center, with the red and blue, and the white on the outside makes the star shine.

I like Star #3.

DeAnna

I like one and three the best.... can't help you more than that!

Kellie

#3, definitely.

Valerie in FL

Star1 is speaking to me, but no matter which one you chose, I'll love it. You have my snail?

(Love your other quilts as well....)

Hullo Kitty Replying before I've read anyone else's!! as usual!

I had to choose between 1 and 3. On balance, I think I like 3 best of all, with the rings of colour alternating. . In article , KittyG writes

I like #3, although its a hard choice between that and #1...

Suzie B

-- "From the internet connection under the pier" Southend, UK

Boy, I had to look at these again and again! They're all beautiful. :) That said, I think the circle effect is lost in #2 when you see it in the complete layout. Deciding between #1 and #3 is truly difficult, but #3 has my vote by a slim margin.

It would be easier to compare if all three quilts were small on the same page so we could see side by side. I can see 1, then go and see 2 & 3 side by side.

With the background behind the stars being "light" I would not use number 2 for the stars..... the white points won't show as well. Why not alternate 1 and 2? Or will that work, I forgot to count how many stars you have....

Pati, in Phx (You are going great guns on this aren't you??)

KittyG wrote:

I think I want to change my vote! I originally voted for #1. But that was based on looking at the individual blocks. As I thought more about it, I thought, Gee, it'd be nice if I could see several blocks together to see how they look. THEN I read the rest of Kitty's message and saw she'd already done that (I guess I was more tired this morning than I thought!). After looking at the EQ5 quilt pics, I vote for #3. I think the circle is more distinct, and I like the way it flows.

Okay, so take away one vote for #1 and add one for #3. Thanks!

message

I liked 'em all, Kitty .... .... but I chose SC1, and played around with the border awhile. I couldn't resist the temptation to give it a little more flow. Here's a pic for ya:

Can't wait to see your final quilt pix. ;^)

DeB Shaw Queen of the *Northern*Lights*

-----

We can make YOU the HERO!

-----

Yes, I thought of that but I couldn't figure out how to do that then upload it all to webshots, need to figure out how to do a webpage.

kitty in phx

Great guns indeed! :) Had to get some practice in paper piecing first and work out how to do it, these blocks are quite demanding in accuracy. Now it's starting to come together, isn't it great when you can make these beautiful things a reality? Don't even ask how I plan to quilt this yet tho....

kitty in phx ~finally off the drawing board~

I vote for #3

Julia > I need some opinions here please...don't be shy :)