Fireline vs. Powerpro

I need opinions, please!

I was recently in a class where the instructor wanted us to use PowerPro for the project. Not wanting to purchase a roll of PowerPro just for that class, I had brought my white Fireline with me (in my little head, they were interchangeable). She told me not to use it, and go purchase a roll of PowerPro (the class was in a bead store, so it wasn't terribly inconvenient to get, mostly an unexpected expense). She explained to the class that she never uses Fireline because it's an inferior product as far as the longevity of our beading projects is concerned. She said that due to environmental concerns Fireline was created so that the sun will biodegrade the Fireline, and so projects made with Fireline would eventually fall apart.

On the flip side, I have been in multiple classes with a different instructor who loves Fireline, and it's the only stringing material I've ever used in any of her classes. She doesn't make any claims that PowerPro is inferior to Fireline, she just prefers Fireline. She says she does all her projects with Fireline, and has never had any problems with the end products.

I have come to like Fireline a lot, but PowerPro also works fine for me. What are your opinions on Fireline vs. PowerPro? I'd really like to know, so I can make an educated decision on which to use for future projects (and which to not re-stock up on!). I personally don't wear the same piece of jewelry day after day, and I'm also not really in the sun all that much, so I'm not terribly concerned with the sun making my jewelry fall apart. I can't confirm the same for pieces that I've made for other people - how frequently they wear things and for how long in the sun.

The pro-PowerPro teacher said PowerPro is not made to deteriorate in the sun, and thus is the superior product for stringing, and the only thing she would recommend for beadweaving or bead sewing projects. But isn't PowerPro also a "fishing line" type of product which might be subject to the same "environmenal concerns" and need to biodegrade?

What are the differences you may have found about using one over the other? Should I not even worry about it for my projects?

Thanks!

Karen :)

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Karen M. Chan | snipped-for-privacy@linkline.com | Whatever Happens... Smile!

formatting link
formatting link

Reply to
KMC
Loading thread data ...

I'd love to hear comments on this too. I always thought they were pretty much the same.

Reply to
Beadbimbo

OK -- where is Kathy N-V? I can't remember is this is a comparison she already made or not. At one point a few years ago, Kathy was independently testing this kind of thing and letting us know which she preferred for which use.

Becki

Reply to
Beckibead

Hi... just thought I'd repost this question that I posted on March 12... I thought there'd be at least a few opinions, but got no opinions at all! I was rather surprised, since a couple of other folks also expressed interested in the responses. I (we, I'm sure) would still love to hear what PowerPro and Fireline users have to say.

Thanks,

Karen

KMC wrote:

Reply to
KMC

Karen, I saw the question but I was still busy with wedding guests. I was really interested in the replies as well. I have used fireline and really like it. Have not used powerpro so can't comment.

Cheers, Jan

Reply to
Jan G

Hi Karen,

I went to another list and asked and was told by several people that they are pretty much the same and that Fireline does NOT break down. I've never used PowerPro, just because I've never seen it, but I have used Fireline and really like it. I'm glad to hear that I can keep using it.

Reply to
Beadbimbo

I've heard the same... that Fireline doesn't break down. I've never used PowerPro so I couldn't comment on the difference between them. I do know that Fireline does fray when put next to a sharp bead... but I've never had the Fireline break. In fact, if I ever want to un-do something I've made with Fireline it takes *forever* to cut it, even using Fiskars. Not something I like to do very often.

One thing I did read about Fireline on a bead group I used to be on... a woman said to condition the Fireline with Thread Heaven before using it, but didn't say why. Maybe to help with any frays that might happen???

Reply to
bluemaxx

InspirePoint website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.